Blog Posts: Charity Evaluation


Organizational Health Standard #2: Financial Management

Posted April 4, 2012 by Al Mueller 0 comments

High performing nonprofits must understand how to manage their money. Charities cannot promise great things to supporters and run out of resources along the way. A delicate balance of maintaining healthy reserves, minimizing debt, and sticking to a budget is required.  Donors don’t want a bait-and-switch where increased donations go to debt service or get stockpiled in the bank without any increased impact. And no one can tolerate financial mismanagement where an organization lives in the red with unrealistic budgets or doesn’t put the majority of its funds into mission-related activities.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Nonprofit Evaluation, Nonprofit Performance, Performance Standard

Continue reading...


Nonprofit Analytics cited as major “charity evaluator” in RELEVANT Magazine

Posted March 22, 2012 by Al Mueller 1 comment

Just days before Nonprofit Analytics turns 1 year old, we have finally been recognized as one of 8 major online charity evaluation and accountability organizations. RELEVANT Magazine published an article “Where Do Your Donations Go?” and listed Nonprofit Analytics alongside Guidestar and GiveWell.  Admittedly, the author chose to highlight and interview Charity Navigator and ECFA leaders.  But the citation in a 3rd party publication is a step in the right direction for what we believe is the best all-around charity evaluation platform available.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Due Diligence, Nonprofit Evaluation

Continue reading...


Organizational Health Standard #1: Leadership

Posted March 1, 2012 by Al Mueller 0 comments

Where do you start when evaluating the health of a nonprofit organization? Incessant headlines about dishonest educational programs, irresponsible board governance, misleading cancer charities, and corrupt first responder foundations remind us a little assessment can go a long way. But most of us don’t have time for detailed due diligence. So where do we begin a cursory evaluation of nonprofit infrastructure and impact?

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Nonprofit Performance, Performance Standard

Continue reading...


How do Family Foundations make giving decisions?

Posted January 5, 2012 by Al Mueller 0 comments

Are foundations making good grants?  I see positive trends to applaud and emulate in the latest Money for Good II study that surveyed foundation giving decisions.  If you want to find out how many hours of research foundations are doing before issuing grants and how much their findings affect new gifts, check out my recent post about Positive Trends in Foundation Grant-making at the Council on Foundations RE:Philanthropy blog.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Due Diligence, Foundation Grant Making, Strategic Giving

Continue reading...


Giving poorly can be worse than not giving at all

Posted December 15, 2011 by Al Mueller 0 comments

What if your donation to fight human trafficking paid the salary of a human trafficker? What if your donation to support widowed law enforcement families went to a felon’s bank account? What if your child sponsorship monthly donation and letters never helped the girl in the picture? What if you gave money to loan to a struggling entrepreneur in Africa that was actually embezzled by loan officers? In the last year, I have seen each one of these nightmares come true.  It could have been avoided. Read how in my latest Alliance magazine article Giving poorly can be worse than not giving at all.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Due Diligence, Nonprofit Evaluation, Philanthropic Advisor, Strategic Giving

Continue reading...


The Rebirth of Generosity: A response to Leon Neyfakh’s Boston Globe article “Why We Give to Charity”

Posted December 8, 2011 by Al Mueller 0 comments

When people think more, they are less generous.  How do you feel about that?  Leon Neyfakh promotes this hypothesis in his new Boston Globe article “Why We Give to Charity.”  Nonprofit service organizations like Law For Change and Campbell & Company have posted the provocative article for website visitors to read.  It has been swirling around philanthropy-related twitter feeds for all to see.  I bumped into it on a daily news blast from the Chronicle of Philanthropy.  I loved its trend-bucking subversion.  But I found its case truly unconvincing.  So much so, I’m firing back with some neglected facts in the oversimplified case.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Heart Test, Philanthropic Advisor

Continue reading...


Evaluating Nonprofit Performance: 3 Questions before you start

Posted November 29, 2011 by Al Mueller 0 comments

Before you evaluate nonprofit performance, stop and ask 3 questions about the charity:

  1. Is the charity trying to create a long-term solution to a problem?
  2. Does the charity want to grow bigger and bigger every year?
  3. Has the charity identified Key Performance Indicators?

These 3 questions are all related to OUTCOMES.  Outcome measurement and outcome-based evaluations have taken center stage in the contemporary debate about nonprofit performance.  I, for one, am a voice and supporter of this trend.  However, we can’t let the trend rewrite each organization’s goals.  Some charity’s just don’t exist to produce the savory long-term, ever-increasing, measurable outcomes that have become all the rage.  So if we are going to determine how well an organization is performing, we must first figure out what standards we can and cannot use to evaluate performance.  

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Nonprofit Evaluation, Nonprofit Performance, Performance Standard

Continue reading...


A Standardized Approach to Evaluating Nonprofit Performance for Every Giver: An Introduction

Posted November 15, 2011 by Al Mueller 0 comments

Endless conversation about “outcomes,” “performance,” and “impact” needs to come to an end.  It doesn’t need to stop.  It needs to get somewhere.  Concrete categories and conclusions need to take shape and either be adopted or discarded.  That is what my next 7 blog posts are all about.  I’m going to lay out a standardized approach to assessing organizational health and performance in the nonprofit sector.

Before I present the six standards for evaluating nonprofit performance, I’ve got to be clear about the pros and cons of a standardized approach vs. a customized approach.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Due Diligence, Nonprofit Evaluation, Nonprofit Performance, Performance Standard

Continue reading...


New Charity Navigator ratings based on old tax forms

Posted October 11, 2011 by Al Mueller 0 comments

I started Nonprofit Analytics because I knew we could do better than all other online charity evaluators.  So I’m biased against Charity Navigator from the start.  Anyone who reads our detailed feature comparison between Nonprofit Analytics vs. Charity Navigator vs. Guidestar knows where I see other major players lacking.  When Charity Navigator announced an upgrade to their ratings system last month, they received a round of compliments.  I myself do appreciate the direction they are going but still see fundamental problems.  I’ve laid out some of those concerns in my latest Alliance Magazine post: New Charity Navigator ratings based on old tax forms.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations

Continue reading...


The Best Online Charity Evaluation Tool: Nonprofit Analytics

Posted March 27, 2011 by Al Mueller 0 comments

Do you want to know if you are supporting effective and efficient nonprofit organizations?  You can.  That is what the Nonprofit Analytics web platform is designed to do.  I’ve stopped blogging for the past 4 months to launch it as soon as we could.

I have been working on this project for almost 2 years with my coworkers at Excellence In Giving.  We have evaluated all other online resources for making smart giving decisions and decided that our platform would outperform all of them.

Tags: Charity Evaluation, Charity Evaluations, Due Diligence, Nonprofit Analytics, Nonprofit Evaluation, Strategic Giving

Continue reading...