Back to Blog

Guidestar is Wrong: Half of U.S. Nonprofits are NOT on Financial Precipice

Print Friendly and PDF

Guidestar announced in January 2018, "Around 50 percent of the nation’s nonprofits are operating with less than one month’s cash reserves." That headline makes it sound like a half million charities could close if people stopped giving for a month. Oliver Wyman and SeaChange Capital Partners analyzed Guidestar's archived 990s from 2010-2014 to make this claim. Suzanne Coffman, Guidestar's editorial director, summarized the data from their study of nonprofit financials in a simple article (admittedly designed to market a Nonprofit Quarterly webinar): "Half of U.S. Nonprofits on Financial Precipice, New Report Finds." That's scary news.

The good news is that Guidestar's information is both old and incorrect.


Misleading Financial Claims

The information is over 3 years old and the headline claim is misleading. The claim that only 50% of nonprofits have less than 1 month of cash reserves is false hype created by messing around with technical financial jargon. The actual data in the report shows that 3 years ago 50% of nonprofits had less than one month of 'operating reserves' (i.e., unrestricted liquid assets). They had more 'cash reserves' than that, but much of the cash was already designated for specific purposes by the organization or donors. The Chronicle of Philanthropy article specifically mentioned "less than one month of operating reserves," but Guidestar chose the general reference to 'cash reserves' to communicate more of a crisis than exists.

In reality, only 20% had less than 1 month of 'cash on hand' in 2014. Since nonprofits live on 'designated donations,' it is misleading to say they are on a "financial precipice" with less than 1 month of cash to spend when they have months' worth of cash to cover designated costs. Donors could stop giving to 3/4 of nonprofits for the next 3 months, and no charities would go under.

The report says $50 billion would be needed to save all the insolvent charities. The Chronicle of Philanthropy posted an ominous image on their article about the study to highlight this point. That makes it sound like there is a giving shortfall. But the real problem is slow payment from clients and reimbursement for services. The 'nonprofits' that depend on 'payment for services' rather than donations build up more debt and less reserves.

An observation in the study itself (page 7) undermines the falsely hyped headlines: "Nonprofits more reliant on private philanthropy (Environment and Animal-related, Science and Technology, Community Capacity) have less debt and larger reserves. It may be that private philanthropy allows these organizations to build prudent reserves in a way that government contracts do not."


Get Your Facts Straight

Guidestar's report could be better named "The Boy Who Cried Wolf (when it was really a harmless dog that passed by 3 years ago)". That's a harsh judgment, but we care about getting our facts straight. Our Excellence in Giving research team gathers 70,000 fields of performance data from 400 nonprofits each year to make sure we have up-to-date and accurate information for making smart giving decisions. Donors who subscribe to our Nonprofit Analytics service get new studies on recent data about nonprofit finances, leadership, and strategy trends every other month. Sign up if you really want to know what's going on in the nonprofit sector.


Add Your Comments

(not published)

IT assignment help

From: Omeo Jones

Students come to us to do it assignment help. If we talk about the reflective essay, it is usually required in a portfolio for admission in higher education. The prices are reasonable and tailor-made for students from a variety of financial backgrounds. Ask us for auditing assignment help.

Assignments Online Australia

From: Keira Tayor

We at always provide original customized, non-plagiarized fast assignments online Australia services. You choose a topic and convey us the assignment requirements through the order form by asking my assignment help; our assignment experts do the rest for you.

business assignment help

From: business assignment help

Stop searching for the business assignment help students can easily hire assignment help services and easily get our more best services from the professional experts of Students who want the best business assignment service for them we are always here without the best team. That's why you can collect top business assignment service easily.

Assignment Help Online || Online Assignment Help

From: Jacob liam

There are so many benefits of online assignment help service. Let's talk one by one about the benefits of online assignment help.

Java Assignment Help

Very Nice and informative post

From: Alan Martin

Can I simply just say what a comfort to find somebody that really knows what they're discussing on the internet.
You definitely understand how to bring an issue to light and make it important.
More and more people really need to read this and understand this side of your story. Essay Writing Service UK It's surprising you're not more popular since you certainly possess the gift.

Great Content

From: Michael

Thanks for sharing! Finances are an important part of of our glass replacement springfield team.

From: Jimmy

The Guiding star works wonders for Us and this is noting that we cannot do without Garage Epoxy Flooring.

From: Sam Terry

It may be that private philanthropy allows these organizations to build prudent reserves in a way that government contracts do not concrete polishing

From: Ellie Greener

I love to collect the expensive wallets of Louis Vuitton because these wallets are so much cool. There are many amazing websites on the internet and the metal roofing contractor bowling green is one of those wonderful websites. I have purchased a very hot handbag of this brand.

Escort in Delhi

From: Vishakha Singh

Many times I have got a chance to read such kind of article and I hope for more in future as well. Your efforts are appreciable and I wish for more in future also.
Escort in Delhi
Aerocity Escorts

Delhi Escorts Services

From: Karishma Singh

I really like the way you have shared such kind of article and I was waiting for this such a long time and I am glad to be here on this website. It is good to know about such kind of info.
Delhi Escorts
Call Girls in Delhi

From: Samuel D. Darden

I read that Post and got it fine and informative. Please share more like that.. candy crush

From: Anton

Many thanks for sharing the amazing tips from this article

Asbestos removal Manchester | Osteopath near me | House clearances Cirencester


From: jefferson

It is a nice blog and thanks for sharing this to us. I like the post which you shared here. Here you will get more about the multi tools which are used in android and dolby atmos apps also get more about the
snap chat messages in detail way.

microsoft outlook support

From: jack jons

Thank you for posting such a great article! I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. Keep up the good work!. Thank you for this wonderful Article!

Electrical Repair Services Dubai

From: Mohammad Hassan

Nice Post. The Chronicle of Philanthropy posted an ominous image on their article about the study to highlight this point.


From: bart

thats kind of sad!
Organic Food Kansas City

From: Horea

Strong points! I bet it took you so much courage to be able to put this up. Thank you!

RD Medical Products - Index


From: Sophie Miller

Je vous remercie de l'information! Je cherchais et ne pouvait pas trouver. Vous me aidé!

From: Cassandra D. Everhart

You have brought up a very superb points , regards for the post.


From: Sophie Marley

The hair salon stylist has been working hard to accomplish so many things.


From: Sophie Gooch

I really admire your efforts. These are really beautiful. I have totally agreed with you. Thanks for providing such information. Instyle Jackets

assignment help online

From: landyrose

Assignment help online is the online service where students can get full knowledge in an academic session.

From: rina

What I think is that everything on is a scam. There is no way something this good has been posted. I mean there are no flaws in it.


From: Ronnie

Wow, didn't realize there is this much dishonesty and misinformation in the US. I definitely need to start researching a lot more to make sure facts remain facts and are presented appropriately. Ronnie -

Thank you

From: Jack

Really interesting information, many thanks for sharing


From: david joe

Stunning, brilliant site design! To what extent have you been blogging for? you made blogging look hollywood jacketssimple. The general look of your site is magnificent, and additionally the substance!. Much obliged For Your work.

From: Charles Cross

Nonprofit organizations come in all shapes and sizes. Educational associations like Do My University Assignment For Me UK, Holy places, and exchange affiliations are a wide range of not for benefits. Charitable associations might be the best instances of not for benefits

assignment help

From: assignment help uk

Assignment Help UK is number 1 assignment help services in UK. If u are looking best assignment help uk like as manage the assignments in Schools and universities.
assignment help uk

assignment help

From: assignment help uk

Assignment Help UK is number 1 assignment help services in UK. We offer the best assignment service like as manage the assignments in Schools and colleges.

From: Jack

Our house removals team really appreciate all the effort that you have put into your blog.

From: assignment help uk

If u are looking best assignment help uk like as manage the assignments in Schools and Colleges. assignment help uk is number 1 assignment help services.

From: Caspar Lee

I really just like the manner you summed up all of the matters and provide us such an informative put up which is surely beneficial for us and through the manner if you want academic help then additionally there may be a platform that's dissertation literature review writing services, Here you'll get every associated steerage from the specialists and it's going to clearly beneficial for you.

إياك نعبد وإياك نستعين

From: Mohammad

تفسير (مالك يوم الدين* إياك نعبد وإياك نستعين ) من سورة الفاتحة
قد تقدم تفسير الرحمن الرحيم في تفسير البسملة فلا نعيد و أما بالنسبة الى (مالك يوم الدين) فالمراد منه المقيم ليوم الدين أي ليوم الجزاء والحاكم فيه والقاضي فيه بالحق والعدل وهو يوم القيامة وخص بالذكر لأنه لا ملك لأحد ظاهر فيه وقد قريء أيضا ملك يوم الدين حيث يظهر الله تعالى للخلائق طرا بإسم المالك المهيمن والملك القهار بما للملك والمالك من حقيقة هي القيومية وسقوط جميع الاعتبارات والملكيات حيث تكون المالكية والملك الحقيقي لا الإعتباري وحيث يكون واقع السلطان والهيمنة لله تعالى متجليا عندما ينكشف الغطاء و يصبح البصر حديدا ويوم الدين هو يوم الجزاء والحساب وله أسماء عدة وردت في الكتاب المجيد كيوم التغابن مثل

From: JustinSmith

The Urban Institute's National Center for Charitable Statistics additionally makes available additives of the FORM 990 via their challenge. They are a exquisite source in case you're doing studies and want get right of entry to to a number of Form 990s or aggregated information. Help Me Write My Assignment

HBR Case Study Solution

From: HBR Case Study Solution

I Personally Like Your Post, You Have Shared Good Article. It Will Help Me In Great Deal.
HBR Case Study Solution

From: Jack

This post has really helped my moling company succeed.

do my assignment

From: david fre

Non-benefits association have worked superbly everywhere throughout the benefactors have a major heart to give their for the reason for philanthropy and help penniless individuals.someone do my assignment

its quality,

From: dff

Apple products are revered for its quality, precision and great design. SRSG started its operations as Apple technology partners in the year 1997.

MacBook pro reseller in kolkata

iMac reseller delhi

ipad air reseller in bhubaneswar

Cheap Assignment Writing Service UK

From: Justin Smith

Submission of a perfectly completed assignment is a huge part of scholar & postgraduate degree programs that most students fail to accomplish. Cheap Assignment Writing Service UK there assignment are considered a proof of a student’s academic studies and scholarly credentials.

From: Lauren Foster

Our educational pursuits, in conjunction with a variety of extracurricular sports, help in honing a baby's talents and ensuring that he/she grows to be a mature and accountable citizen. Dissertation Help UK

From: Mark

Our academic pursuits, along with a range of extracurricular activities, help in honing a child's skills and ensuring that he/she grows to be a mature and responsible citizen.

best School in noida


From: Stipe Jones

To be honest, if everything they want is a reality, in my personal opinion, $10 billion might prove an underestimate. They also need huge expansions in customer service, superchargers, service parts, logistics, etc.Do My Assignment |

Interesting topic

From: dfdfd

Interesting topic shown here, i am now working on it regularly here and would say keep the future posts like this continuously.
top agriculture college in Punjab

From: Anna

They had extra coins reserves than that, however a good deal of the coins become already exact for unique Physics Homework Helper functions with the aid of the company or donors. The actual trouble is sluggish fee from clients and reimbursement for services. It's far deceptive to say they are on a economic precipice with much less than month of coins to spend after they have months really worth of coins to cowl designated expenses.


From: Michael Hussey

Non-profits organization have done a great job all over the donors have a big heart to give their for the cause of charity and help needy people I read the whole blog but didn't get the much things I am looking for more information on this situation and wanted to write college assignment writing uk on this topic.


From: jessica alex

Wow! I’m browsing away perusing your web journal from my lap! Simply needed to say I adore perusing your website and anticipate every one of write my assignment your posts! Carry on the eminent work.Feel free to browse for getting more information about writing work

Tags: Nonprofit Performance, Guidestar, Nonprofit Finance

Go to Blog Home

If you want to receive monthly updates with articles, books, and videos about best practices in philanthropy, sign-up below for the Excellence in Giving philanthropy newsletter.

Subscribe to our philanthropy newsletter